Tavessa.

Fair value assessments: a practical build guide for small firms

A fair value assessment should answer a simple question with evidence: is what customers pay reasonable for what they get? Many assessments answer it with narrative instead. This guide sets out an eight-step build that a small firm can run and repeat.

In short

  • Under PRIN 2A.4, manufacturers must assess value and review it regularly. The assessment must cover benefits, quality, limitations, the total price and the effect of vulnerability.
  • The FCA's most common criticisms are incomplete total prices, weak evidence and treating all customers as one group.
  • The FCA's five areas of focus from May 2023 make a sound structure, and some smaller firms already use them.

What the rules ask

Under the Duty, a product provides fair value where the amount paid is reasonable relative to its benefits.1 Manufacturers must carry out a value assessment and review it regularly, at intervals that suit the product (PRIN 2A.4.2R(2)).1,2 The assessment must consider the nature of the product, including its benefits and quality, any limitations, the expected total price customers will pay, including non-financial costs, and whether the characteristics of customers with vulnerabilities affect the value they get (PRIN 2A.4.8R). Firms may also look at market rates and whether cheaper products offer similar or better benefits (PRIN 2A.4.9G).1

If you manufacture or distribute insurance products, PROD 4 sets your product governance and value rules for those products. Check which rules apply before you use this method.

A structure the FCA recognises

In May 2023 the FCA reviewed 14 firms' fair value frameworks against five areas.3 In October 2026 it noted that a few smaller firms had structured their assessments around those five areas, while making clear this is an approach, not a requirement.1

AreaThe question it answers
Understanding the requirementsDo the people doing the work know what fair value means under the Duty?
Costs and benefitsWhat does the customer pay in total, and what do they get?
Contextual factorsHow do market rates and alternatives compare?
Differential outcomesDo some customer groups get worse value than others?
Data and governanceIs the evidence good enough, and who signs off?

The eight-step build

1. Scope the products and your role

List each product, whether you manufacture or distribute it, and the customers it's for. Group similar products only where the price and benefits genuinely match.

2. Map the total price

Include every fee and charge a customer could pay over the product's life, not only the headline. The FCA flagged assessments that looked at fees separately or left out contingent charges such as arrears charges.1

3. Evidence the benefits and quality

Use data rather than claims: service levels, take-up of features, claims or payment performance, customer feedback. The FCA's good practice examples base conclusions on MI and evidence of customer outcomes rather than assumptions.1

4. Benchmark with comparators you can justify

Benchmarking is one source of evidence, not the answer. The FCA criticised benchmarking that focused on headline prices and left premium pricing unexplained.1 Say why each comparator is relevant, and if you charge more, say what customers get for it.

5. Look at customer groups, including vulnerability

Compare outcomes across groups in your target market. Treating the market as one group, and not comparing outcomes for customers with vulnerability characteristics, was a common weakness.1

6. Set indicators and thresholds

Choose a few indicators for each product, with thresholds and a clear route to action when one is breached. The FCA flagged monitoring without a clear framework, unexplained data limits and no route to action.1

7. Conclude, decide and sign off

State the conclusion plainly (fair value, fair value with actions, or not fair value), record who signed it off, and set the next review date. Write down the limits of your evidence rather than hiding them.

8. Share what distributors need

PRIN 2A.4 also covers the information manufacturers give distributors so they can understand the outcome of the value assessment.2 A one-page summary per product usually does this well.

Before you sign it off

  • Does the total price include contingent and non-financial costs?
  • Is every conclusion backed by data, not just a narrative?
  • Have you compared outcomes for customers with vulnerability characteristics?
  • Is any premium price explained?
  • Does each indicator have a threshold and an owner?
  • Is there a review date that suits the product?

Send an enquiry

Your 8-character Companies House number

We'll only use these details to reply to you. See our privacy notice.