The Consumer Duty board report: what your board should actually see
Every year, a firm's board must look at whether customers are getting good outcomes and decide what to do about it. The FCA has now reviewed 180 first-year reports and is consulting on how reporting should work in future. Here's what the board should actually see.
In short
- PRIN 2A.8 requires a report to the board on outcome monitoring, which the board must review and approve at least once a year.
- The FCA's review of first reports found strong examples, but also thin data, catch-all vulnerability analysis and boards acting as a rubber stamp.
- CP26/23 proposes that a stand-alone report won't be needed. Final rules are expected in the first quarter of 2027.
What the rules require today
Under PRIN 2A.8.3R to 2A.8.5R, a firm must prepare a report for its board, or equivalent governing body, setting out the results of its outcome monitoring under PRIN 2A.9 and any actions needed as a result. At least once a year the board must review and approve the report, confirm whether the firm is complying with the Duty, consider whether its future business strategy is consistent with the Duty, and agree any actions.1,2
The FCA's guidance also expects a board-level Consumer Duty champion.1
What the FCA found in 180 reports
The FCA reviewed first annual reports from 180 firms across banking, insurance, payments, investments and consumer finance. 55 were smaller firms, some with fewer than 10 employees.1
Good reports had
- Input from the business, not just Compliance
- Board challenge recorded in minutes
- Both numbers and qualitative evidence, with clear conclusions
- Analysis of outcomes for customers with vulnerability characteristics
- A check on whether last year's actions worked
Weaker reports had
- Thresholds with no rationale
- Broad outcome claims the MI couldn't support
- Vulnerable customers treated as one catch-all group
- Little evidence on outsourced customer support
- Actions with no owner or deadline
A structure your board can use
- The answer on one page. Are customers getting good outcomes? Where not, what are you doing about it?
- The four outcomes. Products and services, price and value, consumer understanding and consumer support, each with its MI, thresholds and the reason for each threshold.
- Customer groups. Results broken down by the vulnerability characteristics that matter for your products.
- Third parties. What you know about outcomes where others deliver part of the journey.
- Actions. Last year's actions and whether they worked, then this year's, each with an owner and a deadline.
- Strategy and culture. Specific examples, not general statements of alignment.
- The board's decision. What the board challenged, concluded and agreed.
If you're a smaller firm
In February 2026 the FCA added insight for smaller firms.1 Its examples include:
- Using a "critical friend", someone knowledgeable and impartial, to give feedback and informal benchmarking
- Documenting who is responsible for the Duty, because senior managers often hold several roles
- Using external data, such as Financial Ombudsman Service data and trade body insight
- Gathering qualitative evidence from frontline staff, surveys and complaints, without relying on a lack of complaints alone
What CP26/23 could change
On 29 June 2026 the FCA published CP26/23, consulting on the Duty's scope and proportionality. Among other things, it proposes that firms won't need a stand-alone Consumer Duty board report: Duty reporting could be built into existing board reporting.3,4 The consultation closed on 18 September 2026, and final rules are expected in the first quarter of 2027.4
Until final rules are published, the current PRIN 2A.8 requirements still apply. And as PwC notes, the proposals don't weaken the Duty's core aim of good outcomes for retail customers.3 The board will still need to see the evidence. The question is only where it sits.
Sources
- FCA, Consumer Duty board reports: good practice and areas for improvement, published 11 December 2024, smaller firms insight added 24 February 2026
- FCA Handbook, PRIN 2A.8 Governance and culture
- PwC, FCA proposes more proportionate Consumer Duty rules, 2026
- Reed Smith, FCA proposes targeted changes to Consumer Duty, 2026